(814) 878-0003 8th Street          (814) 864-0028 Peach Street       

  • Facebook - Grey Circle

Engagement Rings

We offer a custom approach to finding your perfect engagement ring. Whether you select one of our vintage estate pieces or work with one of jewelers to find the perfect diamond to set in an exquisite Stuller setting, we provide a completely customizable experience to make your dreams come true.


About Us


Erie Gold Exchange is a Jewelry and Coin store that is home to a large selection of engagement rings, wedding bands, certified diamonds, loose diamonds, gold, platinum, and silver estate jewelry. We also have a large selection of gold and silver coins, bullion, graded certified coins, quality wrist and pocket watches, and PLENTY more.

We have been recognized as one of the TOP buyers for Diamonds, Estate Jewelry, and coins in the tri-state area. 


We offer a variety of services to our customers. We do appraisals from one item to entire estates.  We can give a free estimate on what your item(s) are worth based on current market price. We buy and sell diamonds and jewelry at up to a 70% discount from chain stores. 

We also offer XRF testing at both locations. This is state of the art, non-invasive technology that allows us to tell you the elemental composition of your piece to give you the best price! 

Our Services

TWO            STORES
click on either store below to be directed to their page
Screen Shot 2021-01-23 at 10.04.29 AM.pn
Screen Shot 2021-01-23 at 12.01.44 PM.pn

Design Your Own Jewelry

In 3 easy steps

Creating your own jewelry is a simple process whether you design online or in person at one of our two convenient Erie Gold Exchange locations. Choose from our selection of vintage estate pieces or from the Ever & Ever collection by Stuller. Select the perfect stone in store at up to 70% retail price. Have an idea or like a design somewhere else? work with one of experts  on every aspect of the piece to bring your vision to life.

1. Planning
Work with one of our experts to solidify your design with a free rendering and price quote. We can customize an existing piece, combine different rings, or start an entirely new design.
2. Design
View your model, make unlimited changes, and approve the final design.
3. Production
Once you are 100% satisfied with your design, our master jewelers will hand set your diamond in your one of a kind, heirloom quality piece.
Contact Us


Mon-Fri: 9:30am to 5:30pm

Sat: 9:30 am to 4:30pm

Sun: Closed

2256 West 8th Street

Erie, PA 16505

(814) 878 0003

5034 Peach Street 

Erie, PA 16509

(814) 864 0028

Thanks! Message sent.